closed

[exothermia]

Who: Erik, Kitty, and Kurt
Broadcast: none
Action: the Iskaulit
When: September 3rd

[There was an impulse, however fleeting, to delay this conversation. It came and went like a flicker of lightning. No, Erik knew there was no delaying this, and it would be better for all concerned if it was taken care of immediately. He had felt little trepidation when he sent the messages to Kurt and Kitty last night: I need to speak with you tomorrow. The Iskaulit. The responses had come back with differing times, and maybe that was for the best. It could be easier. (It would not be easier.)

A slight measure of foreboding sets in when Erik arrives in the library, enough to keep him on his feet instead of waiting for them in a chair. He knows what will happen; what needs to happen. Everything that happens after is a mystery that he'll accept as it comes.]

Comments

[passingthrough]

Then make it! [Practically shouting out her feelings.] This doesn't make any sense. He's a monster.

[Her throat feels tight, and she knows there are tears fighting to get out but she is not letting them fall. Her hands tighten into fists as she fights back what feels like weakness. Anger is easier.] You... [She trusted you.]

You chose it? Are you still working for him? [Damaged trust. Splintered and waiting to fall or mend, hanging on his next words. Her question shows as much. She knows his Apocalypse is dead. He already said as much, but he could still be trying to carry out his will even now. Survival of the fittest. She feels sick to her stomach. Why didn't she meet him with Kurt?]

[exothermia]

[So am I, is his first thought. He has to take a breath and stifle it, because he's not. He owes it to Charles, to Raven, to everyone who's tried to tell him as much over the years, not to fall back into that hole again. Giving in to his monstrosity was what let En Sabah Nur get a foothold in him. He may not believe much else about himself anymore, but this is one thing he holds on to, as hard as it may be.

He can see things starting to break in slow motion, and part of him says, let it. This is deserved. You mislead her, even if you didn't know back then that this would happen. He doesn't want to be forgiven. Yet Kitty is asking for his reasons. Much as he doesn't want to excuse himself, he owes her that much. He shakes his head, quick and sharp.]

No, I-- turned on him. When I finally understood. [It seems so horrific in retrospect how hard won that realisation was. While he was under the man's spell, nothing seemed to matter but the rage. He flexes his fingers, digging his nails into his palms, needing to move so he can keep talking.]

He came to me a few hours after... after my wife and daughter were killed. [He can't manage that without his voice cracking, but he pushes through it.] I was about to end everything. [The men in the factory, the ones he'd considered friends, who'd turned the authorities onto him. And himself. He'd had no intention of walking out of there alive.]

[passingthrough]

[She wants to keep yelling. Challenging. Lashing out because there's too much confusion and pain inside.

What's to understand about Apocalypse? He wants death and destruction and for what? To remove the weak? It's sick. There's nothing good or right about that. Even the villainous versions of other Magnetos she heard about cared about other mutants even if they went about it in the wrong ways. There's nothing redeeming about Apocalypse's mission or his methods. Nothing!

And yet...

Hearing about his wife and daughter touches something in her and the result is visible. The fire in her eyes that was trying so hard to cover up the hurt and betrayal flickers low. She knows the pain of losing people all too well. She never had a child. Couldn't really. Not in the prison with it's rules. Not home where Piotr had become a prisoner in his own metal form. They weren't able to... It was different. But she had students and she was hard on them—even cruel to them—because she cared. Because she wanted them to survive a world that would be impossibly harsh. But they didn't. Every one of them died like her parents.

She looks thoughtful. Almost compassionate for a moment.]

...I've lost people too. [Her voice is almost calm. Even. Her eyes aren't on his, but they are a moment later as her voice and expression harden.]

And I never did that.

[exothermia]

[His expression flickers slightly, pain and acknowledgement both.

There was a reason Erik came into this conversation believing he'd lose his ties to Kitty. What he had done was unforgivable enough on its own. When held up against the Magneto of her world, the sheer horrors he must have faced and stood tall against even then, he's nothing but a sick and twisted shadow. He wants to apologise for ever seeming like he could hold a candle to that. Because he couldn't.

His reasons aren't enough. He can't claim he never wanted it - he remembers wanting everything to burn, to be destroyed, taken from others the way it had been taken from him. It had only grown once En Sabah Nur touched him, sending lighting through his soul and scorching out everything that wasn't pain and rage. After that his memory falls apart, turns murky, and even the things he does remember seemed far away. It had taken Raven's plea and En Sabah Nur moving on Charles to finally break through to him, let him come back up for air. To know he had betrayed them, and himself.

He touches his thumb to the gold ring, to the silver. He returns his focus to seeing this through. It's the least he can do. His gaze doesn't waver.]

I know. It was wrong. [Maybe, if he'd been able to remember her warnings, he wouldn't have faltered. He'll never know.] I regret it. It changes nothing, but I regret it.

[passingthrough]

Good! [She shouts it back. And takes another step away.

Some part of her wants to forgive him. Comfort him even. The part of her that doesn't want to—can't—lose more people. And he is, or maybe was, one of her people. She'd been worried about him since he went into that coma. She didn't want to think about him going away. There was more to say and know and do. He wasn't her Magneto, but he was becoming her Erik. It made her feel better that he was here with her. With her and Kurt. Maybe he hadn't always done everything right, but who had? She could relate to that better. And he wasn't a bad guy. He wasn't the enemy of the X-Men or humanity. She believed it. She wanted to believe it.

And if she could just bridge this gap now she could have him back. She wouldn't have to be alone with her righteous indignation.

But she isn't ready for that. She has a storm of feelings inside her. Maybe later when the storm expends its energy. When it's nothing left but rain and clouds she'll be able to accept this. Accept the flawed man who was in pain—who had his own storm—and reached out for something, anything that would feel different. Accept that he saw that it was wrong and he came back from it. Maybe he even helped kill Apocalypse. And now he regrets it and he came to her to be honest and open even knowing how badly she would likely take it. He did it anyway. There's something to respect in that. Maybe not a leader, but a friend. He never asked to be more to her. Not this man.]

You're the one who shouldn't be able to sleep at night! [And given the look of him maybe he can't. The comment probably won't even make sense to him. She doesn't mean herself. She means Winn. He's been struggling ever since Sascha was changed by the Atroma for a time and attacked him. She's been trying to soothe that, but nothing ever gets healed, does it? Just more wounded and broken.]

Survival of the fittest is such a joke. Nothing survives. [She turns. She has nothing left to say right now.]

[exothermia]

[He finally steps back himself. There's nothing else he can say. He doesn't want to soothe her, tell her that it's different now, because that's cheap and self-serving. Everything she's saying is true.

"Everything they've built will fall. And from the ashes of their world we shall build a better one!" It had been the siren song, something he understood. He had failed at everything else he tried to do: save Kennedy, get mutants to their rightful place in the world, lead a revolution. Protect his family. All he had ever been good at was killing people. It had been easy to turn back to that, when someone said he could do it. "Reach down into the earth," he had said, and Erik had done so.

He'd once told Shaw he was Erik's creator as a weapon. En Sabah Nur had been the one to wield him.

Erik doesn't move to stop Kitty from leaving, or try to say anything else. He still has one more attempt at this to go.]